Date: October 14th 2015 Episode: American Horror Story Ep.2 - Chutes and Ladders
After starting a relationship with Tristan Duffy, The Countess has some pillow talk with Tristan about the ancient blood virus and also about her past.
In the scene The Countess reveals she was born in 1904! And also that the late 1970's was her favorite decade which gives a flashback to studio 54.
In the flashback, Lady Gaga wears a handmade pin by Marianna Harutunian, available on her Etsy site for $39 here.
Lady Gaga was caught filming the scene by paparazzi on September 10th which is how we know her shoes. For the scene Lady Gaga wears Pleaser Women's Captiva 608 Platform Sandals, available on Amazon from $52 to $85 here.